Crystal Jellies Medium Butt Plug review

A beginner-friendly plug that reviewers consistently call easy to insert and comfortable to wear, though the PVC material means you'll want to keep it to one person and give it a fresh condom each time.

Reviewers describe this as soft, flexible and forgiving — the kind of plug that slides in easily with a little lube and doesn't ask much of you once it's there. The flared base sits flat and stays put, which several people mention as reassuring if you're new to this. One reviewer called it "so far my favorite non-electronic butt plug I've tried", and another said the ridges "feel so good going in and out".

The texture is what most people notice first: smooth jelly that warms quickly and moves with you rather than against you. A few reviewers mention enjoying just the first couple of ridges rather than full insertion, which speaks to how gradual the taper is. That gentleness is exactly what makes it popular with beginners, though it also means experienced users sometimes find it too mild.

The handle is where opinions split. It's soft and flexible, which some people like for comfort during wear — but others found it too bendy to be useful for guiding the plug in, especially once your hands are slippery with lube. One reviewer noted it can be tricky to grip during insertion for exactly that reason.

At five inches insertable and medium girth, it sits in that sweet spot where it's substantial enough to feel present but not so large that it intimidates. Several reviewers specifically called it out as a good first plug, and the consistency of that feedback suggests they're right.

This suits people who are new to anal play and want something that won't fight them. If you're looking for a plug that's easy to work with, doesn't demand precision, and gives you a clear sense of what wearing one is actually like, this does that job well.

It's less suited to anyone who wants a firm handle for control during insertion, or to experienced users looking for something more substantial. And because it's PVC, it's not the right choice if you're planning to share it between partners — it can't be sterilised, so it needs to stay with one person or be used with a fresh condom every time.

PVC is porous, which means it can't be sterilised no matter how thoroughly you clean it. Keep this one to yourself, or use a fresh condom each time if you're sharing. Wash it with warm water and mild soap after every use, let it dry completely, and store it somewhere cool and dry.

Because the material is porous, it will eventually degrade — expect to replace it sooner than you would a silicone plug. Most reviewers got good use out of it for a few months before noticing wear, which is typical for jelly toys at this price point.

Use water-based lube only. Silicone-based or oil-based lubricants can break down the material.

This sits in the beginner-friendly end of the butt plug category — not the smallest available, but approachable in both size and texture. It appears in our ranked guide to butt plugs, where you can see how it compares to firmer, non-porous options at similar price points.

If you're weighing up your first plug, the question is usually whether to start with something like this — soft, forgiving, inexpensive — or spend a bit more on silicone that will last longer and clean more thoroughly. Both are reasonable choices; it depends whether you want to test the waters cheaply or invest in something you'll keep.

Is this butt plug suitable for beginners?
Yes — several reviewers specifically called it out as a great starter plug. One said it was "great for people who are newer to anal play", and the ease-of-use feedback backs that up. The soft material and gradual taper make it forgiving if you're still working out what you're doing.

Is the material body-safe?
It's PVC, which is porous and can't be sterilised. The supplier lists it as phthalate-free, but the material itself means you'll need to keep it to one person or use a condom each time. It's not unsafe in the sense of being toxic, but it does ask more of you in terms of care and replacement.

How easy is it to insert and use?
Most reviewers found it very easy — one said "the jellies slide right in", and the flared base keeps it secure once it's there. The one consistent criticism is that the handle is too soft to be much help during insertion, especially once your hands are slippery. If you need something to grip firmly, this isn't it.

A soft, beginner-friendly plug that does exactly what it's meant to: gives you an easy first experience without asking much of you. The PVC material means it won't last as long as silicone and needs more careful hygiene, but at this price point that's a trade-off most beginners are happy to make.

If you're new to anal play and want something forgiving, this is a sensible place to start. If you already know you like plugs and want something that will last, spend a bit more on silicone.

Available now for $27.95.

This review draws on 144 aggregated reviews across 8 retailers, averaging 4.1 stars. The consistency of feedback around ease of use and beginner-friendliness gives us high confidence in the patterns reported here — enough reviews, from enough sources, saying the same things.

Insertable length: 5 inches
Material: PVC
Non-porous: No
Weight: 0.18 kg
Maximum diameter: Not stated by the supplier
Flared base: Not stated by the supplier
Taper: Not stated by the supplier

The Snug Report is published by the team behind Coy, a New Zealand retailer that stocks many of the products reviewed here. We say so on every page. Our scores come from aggregated public reviews, not from us — the method is on the methodology page and the evidence count is on every review.