Best butt plugs, ranked by Coyscore

Twenty butt plugs, ranked by aggregated review score and filtered for the ones people actually keep using. Every pick here has at least 40 reviews — enough to trust the pattern — and we have led with the ones that score well across beginner-friendliness, body safety, ease of use and satisfaction. Glass and silicone dominate the top eight because they clean properly and last, but a few PVC plugs sit lower down for readers who know what that means and choose them anyway.

We ranked these twenty plugs by Coyscore, which aggregates star ratings and review text from retailers who publish them. Every product on this list has a Coyscore, and six subscores feed it: beginner-friendliness, body safety, ease of use, performance, satisfaction and value. The twenty plugs together account for 5,647 reviews, so the patterns are real and the rankings hold up. Where a subscore matters to the category — quietness does not matter for plugs, so we ignore it — we note what it says and what reviewers meant by it.

The Firefly Glass Tapered Plug scores 92 and leads the list for a reason: smooth enough to use with just a little lube, heavy enough that you always know exactly where it is, and 296 reviewers across multiple retailers gave it 4.7 stars. Glass is non-porous, so soap and hot water is genuinely all it needs, and the taper makes it approachable even if you are new to plugs. If you want one plug that will last and suit most situations, this is it.

The SASSY Anal Plug from Aeystheter Collection scores 85 on 190 reviews averaging 4.6 stars. Reviewers consistently describe it as beginner-friendly and easy to insert, and the silicone is body-safe and straightforward to clean. It is a solid mid-range choice for anyone who wants something reliable without the weight of glass.

Doc Johnson's Classic Butt Plug also scores 85, with 84 reviews at 4.6 stars. It is widely recommended for beginners and users praise the shape and ease of insertion. The material is listed as PVC in the supplier spec, which means it is porous and cannot be sterilised — keep it to one person, give it a fresh condom each time, and replace it when it starts to degrade. Many buyers know this and choose it anyway because it works and the price is low.

The b-vibe Snug Plug 4 scores 84 on 321 reviews averaging 4.4 stars. It is weighted, which some users love for the constant presence it provides, and the silicone is body-safe. The size is substantial, so beginners should look elsewhere — this one asks a lot of you.

Crystal Jellies Anal Plug scores 78 on 139 reviews at 4.6 stars. The material is PVC, so the same care rules apply: one user, condoms, and replace it when it degrades. Reviewers like the softness and the ease of cleaning within those limits, and the price reflects what it is.

TitanMen The Hitch scores 72 on 45 reviews averaging 4.1 stars. It is a mid-range plug with a loyal following, and the silicone is body-safe. The review count is thinner than the top picks, but the pattern is consistent enough to trust.

KinKi Zeus Anal Plug scores 71 on 65 reviews at 4.8 stars. The high star average suggests the people who bought it liked it a great deal, but the lower Coyscore reflects a smaller sample and some gaps in the subscores. Worth considering if the shape appeals and you are comfortable with a less-tested option.

Rocker Butt Plug Large from Electrastim scores 65 on 41 reviews at 4.3 stars. It is designed for electrostimulation, so it suits a specific use case rather than general wear. The review count is low enough that we would wait for more data before recommending it widely, but the users who wanted exactly this report that it works.

We left out twelve plugs because we allow one pick per brand, and several manufacturers appear multiple times in the full dataset. Where a brand has five plugs and three of them score well, we have taken the highest-scoring one and noted the others in the individual reviews. The rule keeps the list useful rather than repetitive, and it means you see the best from each maker rather than a catalogue of near-identical options.

Is this plug suitable for beginners? Yes — reviewers consistently describe the Firefly Glass Tapered Plug as "absolutely ideal" and "perfectly sized for beginners". The taper and the smooth glass make it approachable, and the weight helps you know where it is without being overwhelming.

Is it easy to clean? Yes. Glass is non-porous, so soap and hot water is all it needs. One user noted that the material "doesn't trap any smells", which is exactly what you want from something you intend to keep using.

What is the material of the plug? The Firefly plug is borosilicate glass. The Doc Johnson Classic is PVC according to the supplier spec, and the b-vibe and SASSY plugs are silicone. Material matters for how you clean it and how long it lasts, so we state it plainly on every review.

Is this butt plug body-safe? The Doc Johnson Classic is made of PVC, which is porous and cannot be sterilised. One user on Reddit put it plainly: "No they're mostly not body safe. I know those risks and accept them." If you choose a PVC plug, keep it to one person, use a fresh condom each time, and replace it when it starts to degrade. The glass and silicone options on this list are non-porous and last for years if you clean them properly.

How easy is it to clean? Glass and silicone plugs clean with soap and hot water. PVC plugs need toy cleaner and cannot be boiled — one user boiled a Doc Johnson plug thinking it was silicone and found it became "structurally not strong" afterwards. The material determines the method, and we state both on every review so you know what you are choosing.

The Snug Report is published by the team behind Coy, a New Zealand retailer that stocks many of the products reviewed here. We say so on every page. Our scores come from aggregated public reviews, not from us — the method is on the methodology page and the evidence count is on every review.