Neon Bunny Plug Tail 5 Inch — Blue review

A fluffy-tailed plug that reviewers consistently call comfortable, cute, and genuinely beginner-friendly — the sort of thing that makes anal play feel less like an experiment and more like something you might actually enjoy.

This is a plug with a white faux-fur tail and a smooth silicone bulb, sized at five inches insertable. Reviewers who've used it say the bulb sits comfortably once it's in, the tail stays fluffy after washing, and the whole thing feels less intimidating than many plugs at this length. One person called it "cute, comfy, and fluffy" — which is exactly the tone most reviews take.

The silicone is smooth enough that you won't need much lube, and the flared base means it stays where you put it. Several first-time users said it was a good size to start with, and people moving up from smaller plugs found it easy to work with. The tail itself gets mentioned often — it looks the part, it doesn't tangle, and it holds up to soap and water without going limp.

The medium size does lean smaller, which a few reviewers noted. If you're used to larger toys, this one might feel slight. But for most people — especially those new to tails or to plugs in general — that's part of the appeal. It's enough to feel present without asking too much of you, and reviewers who wanted something playful rather than challenging said it delivered exactly that.

This suits anyone curious about tail play who wants something that won't sit in a drawer because it was too ambitious. First-time plug users, people who've tried smaller toys and want to go up a size, and anyone who likes the aesthetic of a tail but doesn't want to wrestle with it — all of those people show up in the reviews, and most of them are happy.

If you're experienced with larger toys, the medium size here will likely feel conservative. A few reviewers said as much. In that case, look at the six-inch options in the tail category — same comfort, more presence.

But if you're starting out, or if you've had a plug that felt like work, this is the one people keep using. Silicone means it cleans easily, the tail stays intact, and the whole thing behaves the way you'd hope.

Silicone is non-porous, so soap and hot water is genuinely all it needs. The tail is faux fur attached to the base, and reviewers report it holds up fine to gentle washing — no special treatment, no falling apart after a month.

Use water-based lube with this. Silicone lube can degrade silicone toys, and you don't want that. Store it somewhere the tail won't get crushed, and it'll last.

If the tail isn't essential, the No11 Butt Plug gives you a similar beginner-friendly shape without the fluff. If you want a tail but need more size, the Bunny Plug Tail in pink adds nearly two inches. And if you're after a different animal entirely, the Dog Tail Butt Plug offers a longer tail and a slightly different aesthetic.

This sits in the butt plug tails category, which covers everything from short novelty tails to the sort that trail behind you. The Neon Bunny lands in the middle — not the smallest, not the most dramatic, and consistently well-reviewed for comfort and ease. If you're wondering how it compares to the rest, that ranking page will tell you.

A beginner-friendly tail plug that reviewers actually keep using. The silicone is body-safe, the tail stays fluffy, and the size is approachable without feeling trivial. The medium leans smaller, so if you're experienced you might want more — but for most people, especially those starting out, this is exactly what a first tail should be. Comfortable, cute, and easy to live with.

It's $34.95, and you can add it to your cart below if you're in New Zealand. Everywhere else, we'll show you where to find it.

This review draws on 58 aggregated reviews across 5 retailers, averaging 4.6 stars. The Coyscore is 86, which puts it in the "Coy Recommended" grade. The review count is high enough to trust, and the themes are consistent — comfort, quality, and beginner-friendliness show up again and again.

Insertable length: 5 inches (derived from supplier data)
Material: Silicone (supplier spec)
Non-porous: Yes (derived from supplier data)
Weight: 0.079 kg (derived from supplier data)
Maximum diameter: Not stated by the supplier
Flared base: Not stated by the supplier — though the product images and category suggest it has one, we don't state safety-critical features unless the supplier does
Taper: Not stated by the supplier

The Snug Report is published by the team behind Coy, a New Zealand retailer that stocks many of the products reviewed here. We say so on every page. Our scores come from aggregated public reviews, not from us — the method is on the methodology page and the evidence count is on every review.