Colt — every product, scored

Colt's three anal products sit at opposite ends of the beginner-to-experienced spectrum — a graduated training kit that scores 86, and two inflatables that ask considerably more of you. Two of the three are body-safe silicone; the third is PVC, which means different care. If you're starting out, the trainer kit is the one to look at. If you already know you like fullness and want control over how much, the pumper plugs deliver that — though reviewers are split on the XXL.

Colt makes anal training kits and inflatable plugs. The training kit gives you three graduated silicone plugs in one box, which is exactly what most people need when they're working out what size suits them. The two pumper plugs are inflatables — you squeeze a bulb and they expand inside you, which means you control the stretch. The Medium sits at a sensible starting diameter; the XXL does not, and the review split reflects that.

All three are designed to stay put during use, which matters more with anal toys than it does elsewhere. The training kit's tapered bases and the pumper plugs' flanges do that job properly.

Two of Colt's three products are silicone, which you can clean with soap and hot water and expect to last. The third — the XXL Pumper Plug — is PVC, so it's porous and cannot be sterilised. Keep it to one person, give it a fresh condom each time, and replace it when the surface starts to degrade. That's the trade-off: PVC keeps the price down, but it won't last the way silicone does.

The material split matters here because one of the silicone products is a training kit you'll use repeatedly as you work through the sizes, and durability counts. The PVC product is the largest in the range and the one with the most mixed reviews, so the shorter lifespan is less of an issue — most people either love it or return it quickly.

The COLT Anal Trainer Kit scores 86 and earns Coy Recommended, which makes it the standout in this range. It's a three-plug graduated set in body-safe silicone, and 340 reviewers across multiple retailers consistently say it does exactly what a training kit should: lets you work up in size at your own pace without having to guess what comes next. The plugs are smooth, the bases are wide enough to stay outside, and the progression between sizes is sensible.

The Medium Pumper Plug scores 75 and sits in Worth a Look. It's an inflatable that gives you control over how much stretch you want, and 180 reviews suggest it works well for people who already know they like fullness. The XXL Pumper Plug scores 65 on 189 reviews — reviewers who love it really do, but a significant number found it uncomfortable or difficult to use, which is what you'd expect from something called XXL.

The Snug Report is published by the team behind Coy, a New Zealand retailer that stocks many of the products reviewed here. We say so on every page. Our scores come from aggregated public reviews, not from us — the method is on the methodology page and the evidence count is on every review.